Does It Matter What Kids Are Reading?

One question parents often ask is, “Does it really matter what my child reads, as long as they’re reading?” The short answer is yes—but with some important nuances. Let’s explore why the types of materials children read can impact their literacy development and how to strike the right balance.

Reading for Skill Development

When children are learning to read, the type of material they engage with plays a big role in developing foundational skills. Books and resources that match their current level help build confidence while strengthening essential skills like:

• Decoding: Phonics-based texts (like leveled readers) help children practice connecting letters to sounds.

• Fluency: Repetitive and predictable books improve reading speed and accuracy.

• Comprehension: Stories with clear narratives encourage kids to think about characters, plot, and meaning.

  
  

Reading for Enjoyment

While skill-building is critical, reading for enjoyment is just as important. When kids find books they love—whether it’s a graphic novel, a magazine, or a joke book—it encourages them to develop a lifelong habit of reading. Research shows that motivation and interest are key factors in fostering strong readers. Even unconventional reading materials, like comics or fanfiction, can spark creativity and curiosity.

Balancing Choice and Guidance

Giving kids the freedom to choose what they read empowers them and makes reading feel less like a chore. However, balancing their preferences with guidance ensures they’re exposed to a variety of texts that challenge and engage them.

Here’s How You Can Help:

1. Offer Options: Curate a mix of books, magazines, and other materials that align with your child’s interests and reading level.

2. Mix Genres: Encourage them to explore different genres, like fantasy, biographies, poetry, or informational texts.

3. Read Together: Pair a skill-focused book with a “just for fun” option during shared reading time.

4. Keep It Positive: Celebrate their choices, even if they prefer comics over chapter books. The key is keeping them engaged.

   
   

Quality Over Quantity?

It’s a common misconception that all reading is equal. While any reading practice is better than none, high-quality texts offer richer language, diverse vocabulary, and opportunities for critical thinking. That doesn’t mean kids should only read classics or award-winning books, but exposing them to a range of quality materials can deepen their skills over time.

What About Struggling Readers?

For children who find reading challenging, it’s especially important to provide materials that are both engaging and at an accessible level. Books with high-interest topics and lower reading levels (known as Hi-Lo books) can be a great tool. These books combine relatable, exciting themes with simplified text, ensuring that struggling readers stay motivated without feeling overwhelmed.

Pairing these books with supportive interventions, like tutoring or small group instruction, can help build both confidence and skills. Tutoring provides individualized attention to address specific challenges, such as decoding difficulties or comprehension gaps, while creating a safe and encouraging environment for learning. Over time, this combination of engaging materials and tailored support can transform reading from a source of frustration into an activity that sparks joy and growth.

Conclusion

Yes, it does matter what kids are reading—but it’s about balance. The goal is to provide a variety of materials that build skills, spark joy, and encourage growth. At Reading Roots Literacy Coaching, we specialize in helping families navigate these choices to support their children’s literacy journeys. Reach out today to learn how we can help your child develop a love for reading while building strong foundational skills!